Person Page - 1115

     Olive Martindale was born on 7 May 1778 at Westfield, Hampden Co., MA.¹ She married Harvey Hungerford on 9 August 1801 at Westfield, Hampden Co., MA.

     Mary Elizabeth Caldwell was born on 20 May 1848 at Greenwood Twp., Crawford Co., PA.¹ She was the daughter of John H. Caldwell and Julina C. Dillery.¹ Mary Elizabeth Caldwell married Llewellyn Albert Case, son of Cicero Case and Nancy Marienna Hungerford, on 24 December 1866 at Greenwood Twp., Crawford Co., PA.¹ Mary Elizabeth Caldwell died on 12 April 1925 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 76.¹

Mary, age 12, was enumerated in the 1860 Greenwood Twp., Crawford Co. PA, federal census, page 49 (stamped page 337), in the household of her parents. John was a farmer, age 35; Julina was 30. Oliver was 10, Sarah was 6, and twins Elma and Elda were 4.

     John H. Caldwell was born in 1821.¹ He married Julina C. Dillery. John H. Caldwell died on 17 June 1893 at Sandy Creek Twp., Mercer Co., PA.¹

     Julina C. Dillery married John H. Caldwell.

     Fred Lewellyn Case was born on 28 September 1869 at Bazetta, Trumbull Co., OH.¹ He was the son of Llewellyn Albert Case and Mary Elizabeth Caldwell.¹ Fred Lewellyn Case married Anna Estelle Lamb, daughter of David Coon Lamb and Mercy Lovinia Soule, on 9 May 1888 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ Fred Lewellyn Case died on 7 December 1937 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 68.¹ He was buried at Kingsley Cemetery, Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹

Fred and Anna were enumerated in the 1900 Townville Borough, Crawford Co., PA, federal census ED 42, page 13B, the very last family enumerated. He was a blacksmith, age 30, born in PA; she was 30, born in PA. Children in the household were Clarence C., a son born May 1893, and another son, born Dec 1898; all born in Pa.

Fred and Anna were enumerated in the 1920 Spartensburg Borough, Crawford Co., PA, federal census, ED 39, page 4A. He was a stock dealer, age 50, she was 49. Children in the household were Clarence C. age 29, and Maxwell, age 21. Living next door was Donald D. Case.

     Florence Lattin was born in 1886 at OH. She was the daughter of Eugene M. Lattin and Emma Phoebe Case.¹ Florence Lattin married Isaac Watson. Florence Lattin died in 1945.

     Raymond W. Case was born on 9 September 1882 at Sandy Creek Twp., Mercer Co., PA.^1,2 He was the son of Llewellyn Albert Case and Mary Elizabeth Caldwell.¹

     Anna Estelle Lamb was born on 14 February 1870 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ She was the daughter of David Coon Lamb and Mercy Lovinia Soule.¹ Anna Estelle Lamb married Fred Lewellyn Case, son of Llewellyn Albert Case and Mary Elizabeth Caldwell, on 9 May 1888 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ Anna Estelle Lamb died on 15 July 1936 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 66.¹ She was buried at Kingsley Cemetery, Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹

     Donald David Case was born on 8 May 1893 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.^1,2 He was the son of Fred Lewellyn Case and Anna Estelle Lamb.¹ Donald David Case married Hazel Dell Baker, daughter of Fred Baker and Getty Shorts, on 12 July 1912 at PA.³ Donald David Case died in November 1981 at Dunedin, Pinellas Co., FL, at age 88.^4,2

Donald and Hazel were enumerated in the 1920 Spartensburg Borough, Crawford Co., PA, federal census, ED 39 page 4A. He was a stock dealer, age 26, she was 27. The only child in the household was Fred B., age 3 6/12.


Donald and Hazel were enumerated in the 1930 Edinboro, Erie Co., PA, federal census, ED 12. He was a butcher in a meat market, age 46, she was a packer in a stationary, age 37. children in the household were Fred 14, and Beatrice 10.

     Maxwell Case was born on 11 December 1898 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.^1,2 He was the son of Fred Lewellyn Case and Anna Estelle Lamb.¹ Maxwell Case died on 13 July 1931 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 32.²

     Clarence Cicero Case was born on 26 May 1890 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.^1,2 He was the son of Fred Lewellyn Case and Anna Estelle Lamb.¹ Clarence Cicero Case married Marie Joss, daughter of George Joss and Mary Burke, on 20 April 1920 at Erie, Erie Co., PA.³ Clarence Cicero Case died on 4 April 1963 at Atlanta, Fulton Co., GA, at age 72.^1,2 He was buried at U.S. National Cemetery, Marietta, Cobb Co., GA.³

     David Coon Lamb was born on 5 July 1841 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ He married Mercy Lovinia Soule. David Coon Lamb died on 20 December 1916 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA, at age 75.¹

     Mercy Lovinia Soule was born on 12 July 1844 at Richland, Oswego Co., NY.¹ She married David Coon Lamb. Mercy Lovinia Soule died on 27 May 1920 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA, at age 75.¹

     Hazel Dell Baker was born on 12 June 1892 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ She was the daughter of Fred Baker and Getty Shorts. Hazel Dell Baker married Donald David Case, son of Fred Lewellyn Case and Anna Estelle Lamb, on 12 July 1912 at PA.¹ Hazel Dell Baker died on 10 September 1967 at St. Vincent's Hospital, Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 75.

Obituary ( Monday ) Sept 11, 1967, Erie Daily Times, Erie, PA.

Mrs Hazel Dell Case, 75 of 214 Erie St, Edinboro died Sunday at St. Vincent's Hospital following a brief illness..

She was born in Townville, ( Crawford Co, PA ) June 12, 1892 the daughter of Fred and Getty Shorts Baker. She was married to Donald D Case in 1912 and then moved to Edinboro ( Erie Co, PA ) in 1922.....she was a member of the First United Presbyterian Church of Edinboro for forty five years......

She is survived by her husband, one son Fred B Case of Lockport, NY, one daughter Major Beatrice Case, Fort Carson, Colorado Springs, Colorado, one brother Donald Baker of Youngstown, Ohio, three grandchildren and one great grandchild...Two sons Donald and Leon Case, one brother Donald Baker and one sister Mrs Lulu Harris preceded her in death.

Friends may call at the Glunt Funeral Home, 210 Erie St, Edinboro on Monday from 7 to 9 p.m. and Tuesday 2 to 4 and 7 to 9 p.m. and invited to attend services on Wednesday at 2 pm with the Rev George W Das of the First United Presbyterian Church of Edinboro officiating....Burial will be in Townville Cemetery ( Kingsley Cemetery ), Townville, PA.

     Fred Baker Case was born on 18 June 1916 at Townville, Crawford Co., PA.¹ He was the son of Donald David Case and Hazel Dell Baker.¹ Fred Baker Case married Mary Elizabeth Mayes circa 1940. Fred Baker Case died on 17 November 1970 at Lockport, Niagara Co., NY, at age 54.

     Luther Hariph Holcombe was born on 26 November 1847 at IN.^1,2 He was the son of Daniel Kellogg Holcombe and Julia Ann Oliver.¹

     Hannah Hartley was born in 1817.¹ She married Luther Friend Holcombe, son of Rufus E. Holcombe and Nancy Gloyd, on 27 April 1843 at Ripley Co., IN.¹

     Samuel Wheeler was born on 13 November 1824.¹ He married Eliza Ann Tyre on 11 March 1846. Samuel Wheeler married Elizabeth Holcombe, daughter of Rufus E. Holcombe and Nancy Gloyd, on 3 April 1852 at Dearborn Co., IN.¹

     George Hall was born on 3 November 1830.¹ He married Mary Lucinda Holcombe, daughter of Rufus E. Holcombe and Nancy Gloyd, on 26 October 1853 at Dearborn Co., IN.¹

     Benajah Hall was born on 17 August 1855.¹ He was the son of George Hall and Mary Lucinda Holcombe.¹

     Helena Isadore Hall was born on 24 March 1857.¹ She was the daughter of George Hall and Mary Lucinda Holcombe.¹

     Lilis D. Hall was born on 30 July 1859.¹ Lilis D. Hall was the child of George Hall and Mary Lucinda Holcombe.¹

     Parry Francis Hall was born on 22 February 1861.¹ He was the son of George Hall and Mary Lucinda Holcombe.¹

     George Hall was born on 26 November 1865.¹ He was the son of George Hall and Mary Lucinda Holcombe.¹

     Piercy Wheeler was born on 1 January 1854.¹ He was the son of Samuel Wheeler and Elizabeth Holcombe.¹ Piercy Wheeler died on 12 February 1874 at age 20.¹

     Wilson Rufus Wheeler was born on 12 July 1856.¹ He was the son of Samuel Wheeler and Elizabeth Holcombe.¹ Wilson Rufus Wheeler died on 27 May 1878 at age 21.

     Lydia Ann Wheeler was born on 25 May 1858.¹ She was the daughter of Samuel Wheeler and Elizabeth Holcombe.¹

     George Mason Wheeler was born on 25 July 1864.¹ He was the son of Samuel Wheeler and Elizabeth Holcombe.¹ George Mason Wheeler died on 4 September 1914 at age 50.¹

     Walter L. Holcombe was born on 23 September 1856 at Ripley Co., IN.¹ He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

Walter came to Butler County, Kansas, in 1873 and taught in the common schools for a number of years. He also served two terms as Supt. of Public Instruction in Morton County, Kansas.

In 1890 he became the editor of a Populist paper in Butler county, and has been engaged in newspaper work continuously since that time except for the period he has held his present position, which was during the Lewelling state administration and the present administration. He is a student of economic questins and earns a fair state reputation as a writer and worker along the lines of prison reform. ¹

     Ruhama Louisa Lamb was born on 28 December 1871 at Mill Creek, Hendricks Co., IN.¹ She was the daughter of John Tilford Lamb and Abigail Osborn.² Ruhama Louisa Lamb married Daniel Rufus Holcombe, son of Daniel Kellogg Holcombe and Julia Ann Oliver, on 1 August 1900 at El Dorado, Butler Co, KS.¹ Ruhama Louisa Lamb died on 29 July 1934 at Cogar, Caddo Co., OK, at age 62.¹ She was buried at Hazel Dell Cemetery, Grady Co., OK.²

     Daniel Rufus Holcombe was born on 29 April 1901 at KS.¹ He was the son of Daniel Rufus Holcombe and Ruhama Louisa Lamb.¹ Daniel Rufus Holcombe married Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson, daughter of John Henry Watson and Susan Lucretia Gorgas, on 2 October 1924.^1,2 Daniel Rufus Holcombe died on 23 June 1965 at Tacoma, Pierce Co., WA, at age 64.¹

     Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson was born on 26 January 1902 at El Reno, Canadian Co., OK.¹ She was the daughter of John Henry Watson and Susan Lucretia Gorgas.² Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson married Daniel Rufus Holcombe, son of Daniel Rufus Holcombe and Ruhama Louisa Lamb, on 2 October 1924.^1,2 Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson died at Tacoma, Pierce Co., WA.

     Harley Daniel Holcombe was born on 1 January 1926 at El Reno, Canadian Co., OK.^1,2 He was the son of Daniel Rufus Holcombe and Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson.¹ Harley Daniel Holcombe married Louise Land Barber, daughter of Ivy Monford Barber and Beulah Land, on 3 July 1945 at Tampa, Hillsborough Co., FL.^1,3 Harley Daniel Holcombe died on 5 November 1993 at Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Co., OK, at age 67.^1,2 He was buried at El Reno Cemetery, El Reno, Canadian Co., OK.

Harley was an alcoholic before he became a minister. During his ministry not did he serve as a minister, he also was a minister to the deaf and blind. He spent many years working with the deaf and blind as a teacher as well as a minister to them. He transcribed books into Braille for the Library of the Blind in Oklahoma City, OK, for many years even up until the time of his death.³

     Louise Land Barber was born on 2 November 1923 at Cross City, Dixie Co., FL.¹ She was the daughter of Ivy Monford Barber and Beulah Land.² Louise Land Barber married Harley Daniel Holcombe, son of Daniel Rufus Holcombe and Edyth Ellen Eliza Watson, on 3 July 1945 at Tampa, Hillsborough Co., FL.^1,2 Louise Land Barber died on 22 December 1981 at Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Co., OK, at age 58.¹ She was buried at El Reno Cemetery, El Reno, Canadian Co., OK.

     Hannibal Turner Holcombe was born on 31 December 1861 at IN.¹ He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

It is probably this Hannibal who was enumerated in the 1900 Douglass Twp., Butler Co., KS, federal census, ED 8, page 7A. His wife Jennie, was born in Illinois in Mar 1869. Children in the household were Raymond 7, and a daughter Anita (?) age 6.

This Hanibal was enumerated in the 1910 Douglass Twp., Butler Co., KS, federal census, ED 9, page 1B. He was a grocer, age 48, she was 41; they had been married 19 years. Raymond 17, and Anita (?) 16 were also in the household.

This Hannibal and Jessie were again enumerated in the 1920 Douglass Twp., Butler Co., KS federal census, ED 17, page 2A. He was a merchant age 58; she was 50. His married daughter was in the household with her husband, Charles Anderson, and their daughter Myriam, age 1 8/12. Raymond, apparently their son, was enumerated on page 3A, age 27, a merchant; wife Nellie was 24, and son Raymond Jr. was also in the household.

     Charles Frederic Holcombe was born on 13 January 1870 at IN.^1,2 He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

It is apparently this Charles F. Holcombe was enumerated in the 1900 Pleasant Twp., Butler Co., KS, federal census, ED 18, page 4B. He was a farmer, born Jan 1870 in Indiana; wife Leona was born Nov 1870 in Wisconsin. Children in the household were Claude C., born Jul 1895 in KS, and Viola F., born May 1897 in Ks.

This Charles F. Holcombe was again enumerated in the 1910, Pleasant Twp., Butler Co., KS, federal census, ED 20, page 6A. Children in the household were Claude K. 14, Viola F. 12, Noel R. 8, and Avis D. 5.

This Charles F. Holcombe was enumerated again in the 1920, Pleasant Twp., Butler Co., KS, federal census, ED 31, page 5A. He was a farmer age 49; his wife Leona, age 49 was born in Wisconsin. Children in the household were a son Noel R. age 18, born in KS, and daughter Dee 15, also born in KS.

     Mary Florence Holcombe was born on 4 April 1859 at IN.^1,2 She was the daughter of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     Kenneth Morton Holcombe was also known as Rufus Morton Holcombe. He was born on 29 November 1864 at IN.^1,2 He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     Blanche Holcombe was born in May 1867 at IN.^1,2 She was the daughter of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     John Holcombe was born on 25 July 1875.¹ He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     Robert Holcombe was born on 10 May 1878.¹ He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     Paul Burdette Holcombe was born on 10 March 1882.¹ He was the son of Turner Gloyd Holcombe and Sarah Lucinda Walker.¹

     Marie Joss was born on 16 August 1895 at Erie, Erie Co., PA.¹ She was the daughter of George Joss and Mary Burke.¹ Marie Joss married Clarence Cicero Case, son of Fred Lewellyn Case and Anna Estelle Lamb, on 20 April 1920 at Erie, Erie Co., PA.¹ Marie Joss died on 23 December 1992 at Gainesville, Hall Co., GA, at age 97.¹ She was buried at U.S. National Cemetery, Marietta, Cobb Co., GA.¹

     George Joss was born on 7 December 1866 at Grantown, Inverness, Scotland.¹ He married Mary Burke. George Joss died on 31 May 1930 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 63.¹

     Mary Burke was born on 16 August 1867 at Renssalaer Co., NY.¹ She married George Joss. Mary Burke died on 6 September 1935 at Erie, Erie Co., PA, at age 68.¹

     Col. Horatio Nelson Case was born on 24 July 1806 at Granby, Hartford Co., CT.¹ He was the son of Capt. Abner Case and Phebe Smithson.¹ Col. Horatio Nelson Case married Amorette Root on 9 October 1850 at Springfield, Hampden Co., MA.¹ Col. Horatio Nelson Case died on 24 May 1889 at Springfield, Hampden Co., MA, at age 82. He was buried on 27 May 1889 at Springfield Cemetery, Springfield, Hampden Co., MA.

Obituary of Horatio N Case, The Springfield Republican, May 25, 1889
DEATH OF COL HORATIO N CASE
The death yesterday morning of Col Horatio N Case, for over 30 years president of the Pynchon national bank, came almost without warning. He had spent Thursday at his desk in the bank, and never seemed in better spirits. His wife was awakened by a groan yesterday morning, and found her husband dying. Dr. Chapin was summoned, but Col Case died almost instantly from a stroke of apoplexy. Col Case was born at Granby, Ct, July 24, 1806 and was the son of Abner Case, a prosperous country merchant. Col Case inherited his father' shrewd business methods, as well as his fortune. He was associated with his father in business in young manhood and became active in public and business affairs in Connecticut. He was an active democrat and participated in the gatherings of that party. he was elected to the Legislature and served on Gov Cleveland's staff from 1840 to '42, there gaining his title of colonel. He was offered other public positions, but declined them, refusing once to accept a nomination as state controller.

Col Case's interest in banks began with his business career in Connecticut, which naturally centered at Hartford, and he was a director in the Exchange bank of that city. He moved to this city in 1850, attracted by the enterprise of the town which had been quickened by the growth of the railways. For a time he did not enter into active business life, but was employed in the care of the family estate and made successful investments. He became identified with the old Western bank and was a director, but withdrew his interest before its failure in 1857. When the Pynchon bank was organized in 1853, he was one of its most earnest promoters, and was elected its first president, an office he held with but four years of interruption until his death. Henry Alexander was the first cashier and Willis Phelps and Roger S Moore were directors. Col Case was also for many years a director in the National bank of Redemption at Boston. He resigned the presidency of the Pynchon bank in 1858, and was succeeded by James Kirkham, but resumed the position again in 1662.

Col Case's home life has been a happy one. He married Amoret P Root, daughter of Joel Root of East Granville, October 9, 1850, another daughter of Mr Root being married to Calvin Spencer of Hartford at the same time. The double wedding took place in the Court-street house of Roger S Moore, who had married another daughter of Mr Root. In 1860, Col Case bought a house and lot of Edmund Freeman on Maple street,and had since occupied it. They had one child, a girl, who died in infancy about thirty years ago. The house was made attractive, and in later years Col Case furnished it with valuable paintings. Among them is Wordsworth Thompson's famous painting " The Grand Review at Philadelphia in 1777 " ..He was a lover of flowers, and prided himself on his beds of tulips. He often sent flowers to his neighbors, and was especially thoughtful of the poor in the distribution of such gifts.

Col Case came but little in active contact with public affairs. He served on the board of alderman in 1861-2 and did much officially and privately in raising troops for the front. During a term in the Legislature with Willis Phelps he took an active stand against the Hoosac tunnel scheme. Although a life-long democrat, he often acted independently in later life. Personally Col Case was of pleasing address, and his old associates remember him as one of the handsome colonels on Gov Cleveland's staff. He was rigidly punctual and methodical in business and in private life. He was temperate and even abstenious in his habits and carried his regular methods into his rules for sleeping and eating. Although brought up in the strict orthodox faith, he joined the liberal dissenters in early manhood, and identified himself with the church of the Unity. There he was one of the strong men, and of recent years he became attached to Rev John Cuckson, the pastor. Like most men of natural reserve, his chosen friends were few and enjoyed his intimate companionship. Col Case gave for charitable purposes in a unostentatious way. Of the members of his fathers family, a daughter, Mrs Eveline Case, is living near Boston.The funeral will be held from the house, 92 Maple street, Monday afternoon at 3 o'clock, Rev John Cuckson officiating.